When it’s time to gather with friends and family, there’s nothing like starting with appetizers made for sharing. At PJ Lobster House, our menu includes a selection of small plates and appetizers that are perfect for group dining. Whether you’re planning a celebratory night out, a family gathering, or a casual get-together with friends, our shareable appetizers bring people together over delicious flavors.

Read on to explore our top recommendations for appetizers that are ideal for groups, ensuring everyone gets a taste of the seafood and flavors that make PJ Lobster House a standout in Suffolk County.

1. Lobster Mac and Cheese

Our Lobster Mac and Cheese is a crowd-pleaser that’s perfect for sharing. This dish combines tender, succulent lobster meat with creamy, cheesy macaroni to create a comfort food favorite with a gourmet twist. Topped with a crispy breadcrumb crust, it’s rich, indulgent, and sure to impress any seafood lover at your table. This appetizer is served in a generous portion, making it ideal for passing around and sharing with a group.

2. Crab Cakes

No seafood dining experience would be complete without Crab Cakes. At PJ Lobster House, our crab cakes are crafted with high-quality crab meat and a mix of flavorful seasonings. Lightly crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, they’re served with a house-made remoulade sauce that perfectly complements their flavors. Order a few for the table to give everyone a taste of this classic coastal favorite.

3. Calamari

Our Calamari is a perfect choice for groups who enjoy crispy, savory bites with a hint of spice. We serve our calamari lightly fried to golden perfection and paired with a marinara sauce for dipping. The mild flavor of the calamari combined with its crispy texture makes it an excellent option for all tastes, and it’s easy to share among friends and family.

4. Oysters on the Half Shell

For a more traditional seafood experience, try our Oysters on the Half Shell. Freshly shucked and served with lemon, cocktail sauce, and a dash of horseradish, these oysters bring a refreshing and authentic taste of the sea to your table. Oysters are a popular choice for groups, as they can be ordered by the dozen or half dozen, allowing everyone to try one of the most iconic shellfish dishes.

5. Shrimp Cocktail

Our Shrimp Cocktail is always a hit with seafood lovers. Featuring large, juicy shrimp that are expertly prepared and served chilled, this dish is as refreshing as it is flavorful. Paired with a tangy cocktail sauce, the shrimp cocktail is a light and elegant appetizer perfect for sharing. It’s a simple yet satisfying option that’s sure to be appreciated by any guest at your table.

6. Clams Casino

Add a bit of flair to your meal with our Clams Casino. These clams are baked with a delightful mixture of breadcrumbs, herbs, and bacon, creating a smoky, savory flavor that’s hard to resist. Each clam is served in its shell, making it an easy-to-share appetizer that brings a taste of the ocean with a touch of indulgence. This is a popular option for groups who want a unique and flavorful start to their meal.

7. Mussels Marinara

For a more substantial appetizer that’s perfect for sharing, try our Mussels Marinara. This dish features tender mussels cooked in a rich marinara sauce with garlic and herbs. Served with a side of bread to soak up the flavorful sauce, this dish is both hearty and delicious. It’s an excellent choice for groups looking for a seafood appetizer with a bit of zest.

8. PJ’s Seafood Sampler

Can’t decide? Our PJ’s Seafood Sampler offers a little bit of everything! This sampler is a great way to try multiple appetizers, featuring a selection of our most popular small plates in one convenient dish. Perfect for groups, this platter allows everyone to try a variety of flavors and is a fantastic introduction to the seafood offerings at PJ Lobster House.

Why Shareable Appetizers Make Dining More Enjoyable

At PJ Lobster House, we believe that food is meant to be shared. Shareable appetizers encourage conversation, create a communal dining experience, and allow everyone to try different flavors. For groups, ordering several appetizers to share is a great way to explore the menu, especially for first-time guests or those looking to sample a range of seafood options.

Our appetizers are crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients and presented in portions that make sharing easy and enjoyable. The social nature of sharing food brings people closer together, enhancing the dining experience and making every gathering a memorable one.

Visit Us for Your Next Group Outing in Port Jeff

If you’re planning a group outing or celebration, we invite you to visit PJ Lobster House. Our menu, welcoming atmosphere, and attentive service make us an ideal choice for gatherings of all sizes. Whether you’re here for a casual meal or a special occasion, our shareable appetizers and seafood specialties are sure to delight every guest.

Ready to make a reservation? Visit us at PJ Lobster House and let us make your next dining experience with family and friends unforgettable!