Independence Day may have passed, but summer’s still sizzling, and so are the seafood celebrations. At PJ Lobster House, we’ve helped locals across Port Jefferson serve unforgettable summer spreads with the freshest seafood and stress-free prep. Whether you’re planning a belated bash or looking ahead to your next summer gathering, here’s your complete guide to seafood feasting, PJ-style.
Seafood Stars for Summer BBQs
From casual backyard cookouts to elevated patio parties, these customer favorites are made to impress:
Best Seafood Picks for the Grill
- Shrimp Skewers – Quick to marinate, easy to grill, and always a hit.
- Swordfish Steaks – Firm texture makes them ideal for high-heat grilling.
- Scallops – Large sea scallops develop a beautiful sear in cast iron or over open flame.
- Whole Fish – Ask about our seasonal offerings for grilling whole, stuffed with lemon and herbs.
Pro Tip: Coat seafood lightly with oil and grill over medium-high heat for the best flavor and texture.
Takeout & Catering Made Easy
Not into grilling? No problem. PJ Lobster House offers convenient takeout and customizable catering trays so you can serve a restaurant-quality spread without the prep work.
Crowd-Pleasing Favorites:
- Seafood Towers – A visual (and flavorful) centerpiece for guests.
- Lobster Rolls & Shrimp Po’ Boys – Ideal for casual entertaining.
- Baked Clams & Fried Calamari – Perfect for appetizers and shared plates.
Call ahead for custom catering orders or explore our full restaurant menu to plan your event with ease.
Storing & Serving Tips for Freshness
Want to keep your seafood as fresh as the Long Island Sound? Here’s what we recommend:
Storage:
- Keep seafood in the coldest part of your fridge (ideally on ice in a shallow pan).
- Use within 1-2 days of purchase for optimal flavor.
Grilling:
- Pat seafood dry before seasoning.
- Use a grill basket for smaller items like scallops or shrimp.
- Let grilled items rest briefly to retain moisture before serving.
Don’t forget to ask our fish market staff for additional prep tips; we’re always happy to help!
Seafood + Summer = The Perfect Pairing
PJ Lobster House has been a go-to seafood restaurant in Suffolk County for over a decade. Our customers rave about the freshness of our fish, the hospitality of our team, and the consistency of our flavors, whether dining in or celebrating from home.
Local Love:
“The service was excellent. Within a minute of sitting down, warm bread and butter was brought as well as being asked for a drink order. I ordered a 2 lb lobster, which was perfectly done. The steamed potatoes and corn on the cob was great. My wife ordered filet mignon medium rare, also perfectly done. The entire experience was a treat.” – Google Review
Celebrate All Summer Long
Just because the fireworks are over doesn’t mean the fun (or the seafood) stops. Let PJ Lobster House help you make your next summer event flavorful and effortless..
Reserve a Table or call for takeout today.
