The holidays are a time for connection, celebration, and, of course, incredible food. But as any host knows, the pressure to deliver a perfect meal can sometimes overshadow the joy of the season. At PJ Lobster House, we believe the best holiday memories are made around a table filled with the freshest seafood Long Island has to offer.
Whether you are planning an intimate Christmas Eve “Feast of the Seven Fishes” or a lively New Year’s bash, we’re here to help you transition from “stressed host” to “holiday hero.” Here is your guide to hosting a sea-inspired holiday using the Port Jeff Lobster House fish market and catering expertise.
Quality Starts at the Source: The Fish Market Advantage
The secret to any five-star seafood dish isn’t a complicated recipe; it’s the quality of the ingredients. When you shop at our Fish Market, you are getting the same restaurant-grade seafood that we serve in our dining room.
Holiday Dish Ideas:
- The Traditional Feast of the Seven Fishes: Simplify your prep by picking up a variety of local favorites. We recommend a mix of Sweet Sea Scallops, Little Neck Clams, and Prince Edward Island Mussels for a stunning seafood linguine.
- Lobster Thermidor or Butter-Poached Tails: Nothing says “celebration” like lobster. Our lobster specials, Long Island locals love include the freshest hard-shell lobsters, perfect for a decadent holiday centerpiece.
- The Ultimate Raw Bar: Wow your guests with a DIY raw bar. Grab a dozen (or four) of our Blue Point Oysters and Jumbo Cocktail Shrimp. We’ll even provide the cocktail sauce and lemons!
Let Us Do the Heavy Lifting: PJ’s Catering
If you’d rather spend your time by the fireplace than over the stove, let our kitchen handle the cooking. Our catering options are designed to bring the signature flavors of PJ Lobster House directly to your home.
From trays of Baked Chopped Clams and Stuffed Mushrooms to full pans of Seafood Paella, our catering menu covers all the bases. Choosing catering ensures that every dish is expertly prepared by our chefs, leaving you free to enjoy the company of your loved ones.
Expert Pairings: Holiday Wine & Spirits
A great meal deserves a great drink. While you can always check out our full bar menu for inspiration, here are a few pro-pairing tips for your home celebration:
- Champagne & Oysters: The crisp acidity and bubbles of a Brut Champagne or Prosecco are the natural match for the saltiness of fresh oysters.
- Chardonnay & Lobster: A buttery, lightly oaked Chardonnay complements the richness of lobster meat perfectly.
- Sauvignon Blanc & White Fish: If you’re serving a light Flounder or Cod, a zesty Sauvignon Blanc provides a refreshing citrus finish.
Pro-Hosting Tip: Order Early!
The holiday season is our busiest time of year at the market. To ensure you get the exact cuts and quantities you need, we highly encourage placing your fish market and catering orders early. Give us a call or stop by the market to secure your holiday haul. While you’re here, don’t forget to pick up PJ Lobster House Gift Cards, the perfect stocking stuffer for the seafood lover in your life!
Create a Holiday to Remember
This year, skip the generic supermarket aisles and treat your guests to something special. From our family to yours, we wish you a delicious and joyous holiday season.
Ready to start planning?
Visit our Fish Market today or call us to discuss your catering needs!